While purchasing a used SUV, you probably aim to look for something tough, dependable, and built to last; because of that, the Toyota 4Runner is the first name that might quickly spring to your mind.
The Toyota automotive company has earned an extensive, dedicated fan base by maintaining a long history of amazing and satisfactory performance.
However, just like any other vehicle, some model years have stood tall in the market with their excellence, conversely, others should be completely overlooked.
Therefore, continue reading this article to check the ranking of the Toyota 4Runner reliability by year if you’re hoping to buy a used 4Runner or just curious which years are worth your trust.
How Did We Rank the Toyota 4Runner Reliability by Year?
Before jumping into the ranking section, we need to briefly clarify how we determined which Toyota 4Runner model years are reliable and which ones are not.
Thus, we obtained information from several trusted sources, such as long-term owner reviews, expert mechanic feedback, and data from authentic websites like Consumer Reports and Car Complaints.
Furthermore, besides all these sources, we paid close attention to things like:
- Particularly, how often a vehicle requires maintenance.
- Kind of problems (small annoyance to major mechanical challenges) show up in the model.
- The expense you probably have to spend on each repair.
- Vehicle durability, especially over 100,000 miles.
Consequently, we can confidently say that the rankings we are going to present in the following sections of this article are not based on some sort of assumptions.
Top 5 Toyota 4Runner Reliability by Year
Toyota is renowned for its innovative technology, especially in hybrid vehicles. Likewise, since 1937, the company has entirely focused on sticking to its commitment to reliability, durability, and quality.
However, some 4Runner models stand out above the rest of the production of this automotive manufacturing company. It may include:
1. 1999 Toyota 4Runner
The 1999 Toyota 4Runner is widely regarded as one of the most reliable and comfortable SUVs ever built, particularly for off-road rides and challenging tasks.
However, this model belongs to the third generation (1996-2002) of the Toyota series, which may also be considered as the ‘golden era’ of the 4Runner cars for its all-terrain capability, comfort, and elegant exterior.
It comes from a time when vehicles were built tough and simple, to make them perfectly align for daily and off-road adventures.
Furthermore, capability and comfort are not only the reasons people recommend this model; many owners report that its V6 gasoline engines (3.4L) have performed well for a long time, over 300,000 miles (if maintained properly), while the vehicle has not shown any transmission and axle issues.
Therefore, if you are looking for a soldier partner for your forthcoming adventurous trips, this vehicle can be proven as one of the perfect choices.
| Reliability Score | 4.9/5 |
| Average Price of the Car | $3,387 to $5,800 (depending on the vehicle condition) |
| Average Yearly Cost of Maintenance | $514 |
2. 2002 Toyota 4Runner
As the final year of the third generation’s series (1995-2002), this vehicle has represented the peak designs of Toyota’s classic SUVs. Furthermore, by featuring rugged, simple, and developed structures, the company guarantees long-lasting performance.
Firstly, the manufacturer modifies the grille and front-end of a vehicle to furnish a modern aesthetic look for the sleek exterior. Also, for a more polished look, the
Limited trims, such as standard body colored cladding and bumpers, were adopted.
Thereafter, with some minor tweaks, Toyota improved the interior by using better fabric and leather options to provide more comfortable passenger seats and spacious cabins.
Under the hood, a dependable 3.4L V6 engine is combined with a smooth automatic transmission to make your off-road travels hassle-free.
Besides that, the third generation’s models have attained numerous positive reviews, in which the owners stated that this SUV can easily cross over 200,000 miles with proper maintenance.
Therefore, the 2002 Toyota 4Runner is one of the finest suggestions for those who value longevity and low ownership costs.
| Reliability Score | 4.9/5 |
| Average Price of the Car | $4,995 to $12,995 (depending on the vehicle condition) |
| Average Yearly Cost of Maintenance | $514 |
3. 2017 Toyota 4Runner
The 2017 Toyota 4Runner is a perfect blend of modern features and traditional SUV robustness, making it one of the top-rated models in the list of Toyota 4Runner reliability by year list.
It carries the same legendary body-on-frame construction to maintain its off-road capabilities with a strong 4.0L V6 engine and two distinct rear-wheel or four-wheel drive configurations.
However, the vehicle is flawlessly aligned with its rugged exterior and modernized features such as touchscreen infotainment systems, Bluetooth, available navigation, and Toyota’s modern TRD trims, especially for professional off-roaders.
The passenger area of the vehicle is enhanced by durable materials to make the interior more functional and spacious, so that it can easily go with both family life and outdoor excursions.
Lastly, many critics also saw major improvements in safety and tech of the 2017 Toyota Runner while keeping the same mechanical simplicity.
Overall, if you are looking for a sturdy SUV that can deal with both the city and the trail, the 2017 4Runner is a standout option.
| Reliability Score | 4.9/5 |
| Average Price of the Car | $23,371 for a Limited model and $26,177 for an SR5 model |
| Average Yearly Cost of Maintenance | $779 |
4. 2019 4Runner Toyota
The 2019 Toyota 4Runner is prominent for its strong build and reliability as an SUV that stays true to its cross-country trips. It seems identical to the 2017 model, as both come from the same (fifth) generation.
It features a 4.0L V6 engine paired with a 5-speed automatic transmission to deliver outstanding driving dynamics both on and off the road.
Unlike many recent SUV models that solely focus on comfort and tech, the 2019 4Runner continues with its traditional body-on-frame layout, making it an ideal match for the adventure seeker and for those who are seeking a vehicle for challenging terrain.
In the 2019 model, Toyota began offering lower front and rear fascia, wheels, a nightshade package constructed with the limited trim to provide blacked-out badging, and a portion of the interior, intended to make their buyers’ driving experience more satiny.
In essence, if you need a capable, long-lasting SUV that’s ready for both city roads and off-the-grid trails, this model is highly recommended for you.
| Reliability Score | 4.8/5 |
| Average Price of the Car | $22,729 to $43,716 (depending on the vehicle condition) |
| Average Yearly Cost of Maintenance | $779 |
5. Toyota 4Runner 2020
The Toyota 4Runner 2020 continues its legacy as a robust body frame, blending its traditional durability with several modern technologies, and proves itself as a productive and durable at the prior year’s fifth generation.
During 2019, Toyota officially announced that all 4Runner trims (2020 model) would receive Toyota Safety Sense-P (TSS-P) standard, along with the two additional rear seat USB ports. As TRD Pro is associated with the revised grille design to accommodate the front sensor for TSS-P.
Furthermore, it houses a 4.0-L V6 powerful engine that produces around 270 horsepower and 278 lb-ft of torque, paired with a five-speed automatic transmission.
Moving further, according to the reviews, the vehicle set-up isn’t the most fuel-efficient, which certainly helps to achieve around 17 MPG city and 21 MPG highway to offer dependable performance.
Briefly, the Toyota 4Runner 2020 may not match the on-road refinement in some instances, but its combination of reliability, off-road capabilities, and modern technology makes it a compelling option for those who want to experience a classic SUV.
| Reliability Score | 4.8/5 |
| Average Price of the Car | $33,998 to $45,989 (depending on the vehicle condition) |
| Average Yearly Cost of Maintenance | $998 |
In a nutshell, the aforementioned top 5 Toyota 4Runner model years stand out for their outstanding performance, durability, and reliability, making them one of the most beneficial choices for drivers who require a traditional and dependable SUV.
Toyota 4Runner: Above-Average Model Year
After reading about the top-ranked Toyota 4Runner, it’s also worth it for a model year that performs just a step below the best ones. However, these above-average may not be perfect, but they still offer strong performance and solid reliability.
1. 2021 Toyota 4Runner
The 2021 Toyota 4Runner continues with the same old-school SUV roots while just adding modern technologies to stay relevant.
Formally reviewing the feedback, we can say that, after successfully passing the five-generation decade, Toyota comes with a fine-tuned model that is less about innovation and more about refinement.
One of the biggest improvements in the 2021 model was the addition of Toyota Safety Sense (TSS) as standard across all trims, consisting of features like adaptive cruise control and departure alert.
It also comes with the Entune 3.0 infotainment system with a defined touchscreen display that flawlessly supports Apple CarPlay and Android Auto smartphone integration, 4G LTE internet, standard SiriusXM Satellite Radio, and optional HD Radio.
Though its exterior may feel a bit outdated, but 2021 model is a great pick for those who value strength and durability above appearance.
| Reliability Score | 4.7/5 |
| Average Price of the Car | $34,818 to $43,073 (depending on the vehicle condition) |
| Average Yearly Cost of Maintenance | $315 to $956 |
2. 1996 Toyota 4Runner
After facing the sudden drop in the sales of the second generation, the 1996 model was launched into the market as the refined introduction of the beloved third generation of the Toyota 4Runner series.
It was the first vehicle that was entirely designed as an SUV rather than a modified pickup truck, offering enhanced comfort and remarkably reliable performance.
Being available in 2WD and 4WD, this vehicle was a great choice for both daily use and off-road adventures. It also houses either a 2.7L 4-cylinder or a popular V6 gasoline engine to provide solid performance.
Inside, the manufacturer kept the practical and spacious interior with more suitable safety features to ensure passenger comfort compared to its predecessors.
In some ways, the 1996 model may lack modern technology, but it surely respects and stands with its reliability, durability, and powerful performance roots.
| Reliability Score | 4.7/5 |
| Average Price of the Car | $3,639 (depends on the vehicle condition) |
| Average Yearly Cost of Maintenance | $510 to $836 |
3. 2009 Toyota 4Runner
The 2009 Toyota 4Runner is a part of the fourth generation (2003-2009), and is known for its sudden change in exterior styling. However, there were many disappointments shown by the buyers because the SUV has lost its traditional charm immensely.
Moreover, it comes with either a 4.0L V6 engine or a 4.7L V8, both providing strong and reliable performance.
Likewise, the availability of 4WD, good ground clearance, and features like hill descent control (in some trims) facilitate drivers’ smooth rides on city streets, highways, and off-road.
Apart from that, one of the notable features about this model is that it gives an impressive towing capacity of up to 7300 pounds, making it a great option for transporting trailers.
Finally, despite numerous modifications, rusting issues with the 2009 model may occasionally be discovered.
| Reliability Score | 4.7/5 |
| Average Price of the Car | $8,679 to $11,930 (depending on the vehicle condition) |
| Average Yearly Cost of Maintenance | $514 |
Hence, the above-mentioned average Toyota 4Runner reliability by years might lack modern technology or appearance, but it still offers the same strong performance and lasting value as compared to the leading ones.
Toyota 4Runner: Decent But Not Acceptable
In this section, we’re going to look at the Toyota 4Runner models that seem fine at first but might come with problems that you should entirely ignore. While these cars might serve some people well, they may not meet certain essential needs.
Therefore, if you’re thinking about buying one, it’s better to take a closer look to make a strategic decision.
1. 2013 Toyota 4Runner
Just like any other model of Toyota, this vehicle is known for its traditional durability and support for its buyers. It has a strong V6 engine and a spacious interior, making it more comfortable for passengers.
However, according to NHTSA reports, the 2013 4Runner has officially recorded 6 recall issues. This may include a stiff or bumpy ride on regular roads, an airbag inflator exploding, and a minor disturbance with the braking system.
Furthermore, many owners also complained that the vehicle’s fuel economy is not very good, and the steering performance may seem less precise compared to the other SUVs.
Lastly, several customer reviews also indicate that the interior of the 2013 model is a little outdated, with less advanced modern technology than other vehicles of the same year.
Therefore, this 4Runner still stands with its roots, but it will be good if you go with another model of Toyota to avoid any sort of inconvenience in the future.
| Reliability Score | 4/5 |
| Average Price of the Car | $8,806 to $11,833 (depending on the vehicle condition) |
| Average Yearly Cost of Maintenance | $559 |
2. 2003–2005 Toyota 4Runner
The 2003-2005 4Runner is known for its strong performance and capabilities, but it also comes with some major issues.
NHTSA reports state that vehicles introduced in these respective years face the problem of rust, especially on the frame, which can be a bit expensive to fix. Furthermore, some buyers also report constant complications with the suspension and the rear window.
According to the reviews, sometimes drivers face a rough ride, also the car’s fuel economy is below average. Moreover, while the vehicle offers the V8 option that leads to good power, conversely, it leads to poor gas mileage.
Overall, 2003-2005 year models are old and follow their long history of being tough and reliable, but their common drawbacks make them a risky purchasing decision if not checked properly.
Final Thoughts
To sum it up, Toyota 4Runner reliability by year has earned an authentic legacy of being a reliable SUV for over a decade. However, not every model year can perform the same. Some years are praised for their strong and durable performance, while a few have to face negative feedback.
In the final analysis, after thoroughly reading this article, we are sure this little research can go a long way in helping you avoid expensive repairs or unexpected challenges during your off-road trips.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is there any Toyota 4Runner model year I should completely avoid?
Ans: Toyota is widely known for its reliability, but the 4Runner models introduced between 2003 and 2009 should be avoided entirely because they reported significantly more issues than the other models.
2. Is the Toyota 4Runner costly to maintain and service?
Ans: The Toyota 4Runner is not expensive to maintain; it might cost you approximately $6,492 over a 10-year period, which is below the average industry ratio compared to other SUV models.
3. Do newer models of the Toyota 4Runner have fewer issues than previous versions?
Ans: Yes, critics were expecting fewer faults in the models introduced in 2025, due to improvements in reliability and the addition of modern technology in the vehicle.
4. Is the 2016 Toyota 4Runner worth purchasing?
Ans: The 2016 model year vehicle is widely known for its performance, but it may not be well-suited for everyone’s choice according to their needs and preference. We can consider it an average vehicle.
5. What are the best 4Runner years of Toyota?
Ans: Toyota’s 1999, 2002, 2017, and 2019 are considered as the finest years of the overall long history of this automotive manufacture company. That received an immense public support and critics positive reviews.